Frosted Cookies

Collection: Frosted Cookies

Cookie FAQ

Answers to all your cookie questions.

What is buttercream frosting?

Buttercream frosting is a deliciously sweet mixture made by combining butter and sugar and whipping the combination to a creamy texture. 

Our frosted cookies are topped with a decadently smooth layer of buttercream frosting that perfectly complements the soft, sweet cookie underneath. The rich flavor of our buttercream is why these are part of our collection of bestsellers

If you're looking for a gift for someone who loves sweets, our frosted cookies are always a delight.

What is the shelf life of buttercream frosted cookies?

Our buttercream frosted cookies are individually packaged to ensure they stay fresh for as long as possible. For the best experience, we recommend eating your baked goods as soon as they arrive. 

The good news is that our frosted cookies and other baked treats have a shelf life of 12 days. Make sure you store all baked goods in an airtight container and keep individually wrapped products sealed for maximum freshness.

How do I store frosted buttercream cookies?

While our cookies, brownie bites, and other baked goods have a shelf life of 12 days, you can freeze them if you want to keep them fresh for longer. 

Make sure to freeze your buttercream cookies in their original sealed packaging. When you're ready to eat your frozen cookies, you can thaw them out or put them in the oven or microwave for a fresh, hot cookie. 

Freezing our cookies can keep them tasty for up to 6 months, but we still recommend enjoying your frosted cookie delivery as soon as possible.

Can I order buttercream cookies for specific occasions?

You can find frosted buttercream cookies for every occasion. Many of our cookies are available in themed gift tins that are perfect for holidays, birthdays, and other special events. We also have buttercream cookies with different designs and frosting colors, so you can always find something to fit your theme. 

We carry an assortment of gift baskets and cookie tins for occasions like graduations, Mother's Day, Father's Day, and work anniversaries.

When will my frosted buttercream cookies arrive?

We do our best to deliver your cookies quickly, but we can't guarantee a delivery date for standard ground shipping. 

If you need your frosted sugar cookies delivered by a specific day, you can choose one of our guaranteed delivery methods to ensure they arrive on time. 

Extreme weather can also cause delays in shipping, so you may want to order ahead of time during peak seasons, such as fall and winter. 

Fortunately, all treats, including our berries and fresh fruit and frosted cookies, are delivered fresh.